ST Voyager Revs -- Alliances
Star Trek Voyager Reviews Written by Someone Who Actually LIKES the Show! -- Alliances
Please Click here.
Gather 'round, you who have traveled far and wide to learn of the story of that day, the story of betrayal and lost dreams, the story of a brotherhood dead to its own soul, the story of a war that would not be stopped, a thirst for blood which would not be slaked, a story of...oh, you get the idea.
Actually, this is my review of the Star Trek Voyager episode, "Alliances," which is quite good (the episode -- I can't speak for the review). This work is intended expressly for the enjoyment of Voyager fans and maybe a few people who just can't wait for the next Mario Puzo book. The rest of you may go elsewhere for your fun and games.
How about Pig Decoy Carving?
No? It really is an art! Okay then...
PLOT
Maj Culluh comes to Janeway to ask a favor, and Janeway says, "Yes, you badly coifed dog, I will do this favor, but you must remember that you owe me this favor. Someday I will want a favor, and you -- What? You say the Godfather thing is getting old? All right, I'll wait for the wormhole.
The Kazon have attacked Voyager, and the ship beats off the Kazon only after their weapons, shields, engines, and Janeway's hair have suffered heavy damage. There are many casualties, including Crewman Bendare. The Doctor tries hard to save him, but there's too much damage. Janeway's hair, however, fixes right up!
[Has anyone else noticed that the Kiss of Death for character is that cortical stimulator? As soon as Doc slaps one on Bendare's forehead, we know he's a gonner.]
Chakotay reports the damage to Janeway in her ready room and then urges her to think about making some changes in her stiff Starfleet attitude. "Starfleet works well in the Alpha Quadrant," he says, "but out here maybe we should be thinking like the Maquis." Like the Maquis, they are on their own, outmatched by their predators. Janeway resists the whole idea, but notes that Chakotay has a point about their circumstances.
They hold a memorial service for Bendare, who once saved Torres' life once and helped out Chakotay in a fight with some Maquis who didn't like his sense of humor (Hey! At least they've seen his sense of humor). Chakotay keeps a stiff upper lip [What does that expression mean???] while he says that Bendare fought "the good fight" and some guy blows the memorial service whistle.
With Jonas at his shoulder, Hogan confronts Janeway and says she should turn over whatever technology the Kazon want to get passage through this section of space. Janeway tells him she'll destroy the ship before she'll let the Kazon get their dirty hands on it, and we can see that Hogan is more than a little surprised by her determination.
Alone with Janeway in the turbo-lift, Chakotay urges Janeway again to soften her stance against the Kazon, going so far as to suggest an alliance with a sect or two. This freaks Janeway out so much she goes to ask Tuvok his opinion. Tuvok surprises her further by agreeing with the possibilities of such an alliance. He even mentions Spock's radical decision to create an alliance between the Federation and the Klingon Empire. Perhaps Voyager could introduce a momentary stability to this section of space, one that lasts long enough, anyway, for Voyager to get out of the area.
In the conference room, Janeway informs the command crew that she's decided to pursue the possibility of an alliance with the Kazon. Kim, of course, objects, but she squashes him like a little bug. Neelix more helpfully suggests that he go to the planet Sobrus to look up an old friend with a Kazon connection. Kim jokingly suggests they give Seska a call, but Torres takes it seriously. Janeway decides to contact her, even though she looks incredibly unhappy about the whole thing.
Voyager gets Culluh and Seska on the viewscreen and they arrange a rendezvous. Janeway looks even more unhappy.
Neelix goes to a seedy bar on Sobrus complete with a dancing sexy alien chick (but at least she doesn't have three breasts). There, he finds his acquaintance, Tersa, who's playing a game of matchsticks. Their little talk, however, is interrupted when Neelix is arrested by some badly-coifed Kazon thugs.
Janeway meets with Culluh and Seska, and all three thump their chests until Culluh makes a silly demand that they exchange crews. It seems Culluh just can't resist the opportunity to sneer at the whole idea of women with power, and, looking like she's just had to French-kiss the class nerd, Janeway stands up and calls an end to the whole meeting. This was, she says, a bad idea.
Neelix gets tossed into a cave prison with a bunch of Trabe refugees. As you might remember, the Trabe once held the Kazon enslaved, but about a generation ago the Kazon rebelled. Now the Kazon pursue the Trabe and give them no rest. This particular group of Trabe is commanded by Mabus, whose ship was attacked five days ago by the local Kazon.
Voyager finds no trace of Neelix at the rendezvous site. With her expression sending little daggers at Chakotay, Janeway decides to wait two hours for him to show up.
Down in engineering, Hogan urges Torres to dodge Janeway's authority and contact Seska directly. Torres says Seska isn't the person they thought she was, and, when Hogan persists, snarls in Janeway's defense (yeah!) and tells Hogan he's got no justification to criticize Janeway. His biggest worry is checking the dilithium in the engines, while Janeway is trying to get them home.
Jonas' ears prick up.
Neelix throws in his lot with these Trabe prisoners. Soon, there's the sound of phaser fire. A ball-like grenade rolls to the foot of the Kazon guard. BOOM! The prisoners escape.
Janeway gets ready to head to Sobrus with weapons charged, but an armada of Kazon ships approaches. Ready for the Big Fight, Janeway hails the lead ship -- only to be confronted with a smug Neelix on the viewscreen. He introduces Mabus, and they decide to talk over dinner.
At dinner, Mabus describes the Trabe's past abuses of the Kazon. They used to keep them as slaves, though he himself didn't realize how bad things were. Now he feels ashamed, and the children of his people are completely innocent of the atrocities committed upon the Kazon. Now all the Trabe want is peace, and a little place to call their own. Janeway seems touched by all this and serves Mabus wine. Well, it's not pecan pie, but it's something!
Jonas secretly contacts the Kazon and speaks to Rettik. He wants to talk to Seska, but Rettik says Jonas must prove his worth first.
In the ready room, Neelix tells Tuvok, Chakotay and Janeway about how the Trabe used to be respected throughout the sector for their wealth and power. Chakotay says the Trabe do seem to have learned their lesson. Tuvok says an alliance with the Trabe wouldn't help their cause with the Kazon, but Janeway knows they have no Kazon friends. She says it's Starfleet policy to trust until proven otherwise, and she'd rather join with the Trabe than the Kazon.
The Doctor checks the Trabe out and gives their cute little Trabe kids some vitamin shots. Janeway tells Mabus of her alliance idea, and he instantly expands the scope of it to include a peace meeting with all the Kazon leaders. The idea of being a peacemaker tempts Janeway in a major way. Her eyes sparkle with the whole idea.
The engraved invitations go out, and Culluh and Seska bicker about his handling of Janeway's offer. Seska basically orders Culluh to go to the meeting and scope things out.
Right before the scheduled conference, a worried Neelix tells Janeway he's heard of a man arrested for sketching a drawing of the conference room. Someone is planning something. Tuvok and Janeway agree that they should watch out for whoever tries to leave the conference room first. Chakotay wants to back out of the whole thing, but Janeway orders him instead to keep a transporter lock on the away team. She leaves for the conference with Tuvok and Neelix, and it's clear from the look on Chakotay's face that he wonders what he's started.
In the conference room, Tersa brags about the decor to Neelix, who's worried about how this is all going to work out. Janeway, Tuvok and Mabus arrive, then Tersa introduces the Kazon leaders, who snarl at her.
They sit at Tersa's beloved triangular table and snarl some more. While Tuvok keeps careful watch for the first person who looks like they're going to cut out, Culluh makes it clear that he's not interested in any offer that comes from a WOMAN and a Trabe.
Mabus suggests a withdrawal into conference, and Janeway's wide eyes fix on him in suspicion. The table shakes, and Janeway calls out a warning to the Kazon leaders, who take cover. A Trabe shuttle appears out the window and starts firing. Janeway, Tuvok, Neelix, and Mabus are beamed out as Voyager fires on the shuttle and foils the assassination attempt. The Kazon leaders leave their cover, snarl, and return to their ships.
In the transporter room, Mabus is disappointed that Janeway has ruined this great "chance for peace" in the killing of the Kazon leaders. Suffering from a major case of the "You betrayed me, you bastard," Janeway orders Mabus off her ship. With something like relish, Tuvok pushes Mabus onto the transporter pad and they beam him off. Janeway has Paris get them the heck out of there.
In the conference room, Janeway gets reports from her crew which assure her that they can go for weeks without stopping. Perhaps they can put enough distance between themselves and the Kazon...
In the meantime, Janeway says (mostly to Chakotay) that out here in this hostile sector of space, with no friends to help them, their best allies are their Federation ideals. She won't be bending them again.
CHARACTER
Okay, I've seen Janeway take an awful lot of heat about this episode, and I want to say right off that I feel it's completely unjustified. She does what any captain has to do: she relies on the good judgment of her officers. Then when her initial objections are proven correct, she points out to everyone that they've made a mistake and won't make it again. What the hell else do you want from her?
Well, people seem to want her to fire a lot of phasers at everyone and claim to have some corbomite in her pocket until they do what she says. That would be very satisfying, I'm sure, but, thankfully for the good of the show, it ain't gonna happen.
Not surprisingly, then, I get true joy out of watching Torres defend Janeway when Hogan attacks. Torres had been the victim of The Look once. Never again.
But more than that, Torres has had her own experience with command for awhile. She's got a real feeling for how hard it is to make the Big Decisions. Hogan just wants to get home.
Hogan will be a great character to watch in the future. He stands in for the Maquis who didn't get promoted to the command crew. Watching him (I hope) grow in respect for the Starfleet crew, the ship, and ultimately Janeway will be a real pleasure.
[Q! Come back here, you jerk! What? Where am I? Oh, sorry guys. This is Julia. One minute I was standing next to this volcano arguing with Q about how we humans didn't just evolve from a little puddle of goo, and now here I am back in 20th century, though not quite to my present time. Hmm, what was I concerned about back here in the second season of Voyager? Oh yeah, I was stupidly thinking about how great a character Mr.. Hogan was going to be. Well, suffice to say this didn't work out the way I planned. In what was by far the dumbest thing he's ever done -- and that's saying something! -- Neelix ordered Hogan to pick up some bones in "Basics 2" and he got eaten by a snake! So much for liking minor characters. Oh! There you are, Q! Return me to my correct time immediately! NO! I'm not going to carry your child!]
THOUGHT
We get to see Voyager's crew grapple with some really heavy issues in this one, and if the ending isn't a surprise to us, that's only because it's the most logical ending the episode could have.
First of all, I really like the way Chakotay is extremely comfortable urging Janeway to take action and join alliances, then hates the whole thing once it gets started. Like so many second bananas, he thinks he knows what it means to command, and has suggestions aplenty. But also like so many second bananas, he really doesn't see the Big Picture. Somehow the idea of actually having to snuggle up to the Kazon, including Seska, doesn't occur to him until it's actually right in front of him, and when the peace conference looks fishy he doesn't want to go at all. We get the feeling he regrets his big mouth long before the last commercial break.
In fact, there's a nicely subtle hint right at the beginning that tells us how little thought Chakotay has really given the whole thing. He tells Janeway they should align with a Kazon faction "or two," as if they were clubs Voyager could join singly or in groups. While it's not exactly a mistake written in Chakotay's blood, there's nothing casual or incidental in how many Kazon Voyager's crew ally themselves with.
Janeway's attitude, by contrast, is first resistant, then wonderfully pragmatic about the whole thing once she decides to go forward. Her line to Chakotay is perfect: "You can't have it both ways, Commander. If you want to get in the mud with the Kazon, you can't complain that you might get dirty." She'll talk to Seska, she'll put up with Culluh's garbage, she'll trust someone she barely knows, because that's what's called for. Whether she likes doing it or not isn't important.
Where Janeway does slip up a bit is in not resisting the temptation to play peacemaker. This temptation is similar to one Torres got last week in "Prototype" when she was asked to play God. As captain, we would expect Janeway to recognize the temptation's danger. However, Janeway gets asked by people she knows (ostensibly) more about, and playing "peacemaker" isn't exactly in the same category as being a "Builder."
Still, she should be more resistant to the idea of playing so large a role in the peace talks, even if peacemaking is the Federation's favorite handicraft. It's another lesson that one step off the path leads deep into the dark forest, a lesson she herself reiterates at the episode's end. Starfleet's regulations really are meant for the crew's protection, no matter what quadrant they're in.
And, come to think of it, it's nice that the captain herself has to be reminded of that from time to time.
Another lesson appearing in both this episode and "Prototype" is to beware politeness. Like 3947, Mabus says all the things Voyager's crew wants to hear. Someone who tells you that probably wants something from you that you won't want to give. Still, it's hard to know how this lesson can be applied: should Voyager only listen to rude people?
The exchange between Seska and Culluh raises some nicely ugly issues. Culluh's incredibly blatant and offensive sexism is meant, it seems to me, to be a throw-back to our own history (and to other cultures still doing very well here on Earth). It's easy to despise him for it. But I note also that his behavior draws from Seska an equally repulsive female response. She's manipulative in all the ugly ways sexist men like to accuse women of being. She uses her pregnancy, her sexual appeal, a combination of compliments and nagging, and basic brow-beating to get Culluh to do what she wants. The idea seems to be that in a world where women are not allowed overt power, they take it as best they can.
Now, I'm the last person to defend Seska, but she's being shoved into a position here that makes her even more loathsome than she would otherwise be. In making her alliances, Seska has had to sacrifice much that the Federation allowed her. Even on Cardassia, women are allowed more authority than with the Kazon. Every time she has to force her eyes to the ground and say "Yes, Culluh," Seska demonstrates what her dealings have cost her, and this gives her great motivation for hating Voyager's crew all the more, and for beating those Federation pansies into a pulp for making her pay that price.
SPECTACLE
All that bad hair in one place. Maybe Janeway should have let the Trabe blow up the Kazon after all.
DICTION
Good lines in this one include that thing about Kazon mud, and:
"If you suggest we abandon our principles just because we're out of hailing range..." -- Janeway to Chakotay.
"How can this one ship survive?" "Not by making deals with executioners." -- Mabus and Janeway.

SONG
Terrific music, and played by real people who have never been enslaved by synthesized music!
And now for the baggage...
STAR TREK ELEMENTS WE (I OR, ANYWAY) LOVE
Well, I may be all alone on this one, but I love it when Trek ships get a reaffirmation of their faith in Starfleet rules and regs. Frankly, most of the rules I follow at work really do seem to be pointless. Wouldn't it be wonderful if I could fail to turn in some form or other and learn that it made a real difference to someone other than the secretary?
Anyway, Janeway and company get to see that however difficult it may be to maintain Federation rules in the Delta Quadrant, it will be much harder not to maintain them.
STAR TREK ELEMENTS WE (OR I, ANYWAY) HATE
I must admit, I'm getting tired of the Kazon. When are we going to see the end of these jerks, anyway?
And will Jonas go with them? Please?
Well, that wraps up yet another one!
Star Trek Voyager Reviews
Go on to ST Voyager Reviews -- Threshold.
Or go back to ST Voyager Reviews -- Prototype.
Or go to Jim Wright's review for a second opinion.
Click Homespon@aol.com to send me some e-mail or I will send some thugs to gun you down!
|