The Hippo/Rhino Question
or
Who's Number Two?


Back Return to Wild Hippos

Back Return to Hippo World - Table of Contents

A Weighty Question

Everyone agrees that the elephant is the largest living land animal, by weight, in the world. But which land animal is the second largest? Is it the common hippopotamus (Hippopotamus amphibius) or the White rhinoceros (Ceratotherium simum)?


The Experts Don't Agree

I have come across many reputable sources which state that the hippo is the world's second-largest land animal. However, there are a comparable number of sources--just as reputable--which say that the "Number Two" title goes to the White rhino. A few sources even bestow the honor on the Indian rhinoceros (Rhinoceros unicornis). So whom are we to believe?


You Be The Judge

The lists below summarize most of the information I have found on this subject. Because of my peculiar passion for the hippo, I believe that it should be recognized as the world's second-heaviest land animal, with the White rhino a close third. I could be biased, of course, so I will leave it to you to consider the information I have to offer and form your own opinion.


How this page is organized

This page is divided into four sections:

Part 1: Hip Hippo Hooray!

Sources stating that hippo is 2nd largest



Top of Page Return to How This Page Is Organized

Part 2: Rah Rah Rhino!

Sources stating that rhino is 2nd largest



Top of Page Return to How This Page Is Organized

Part 3: Fight! Fight!

What if a hippo and a rhino duked it out?

The preceding discussion raises an interesting question (at least, it does in my mind): If a hippopotamus and a rhinoceros got into a fight, which one would win? The two animals are of comparable size, both have formidable weapons (the rhino's horns vs. the hippo's tusks), and both are fierce fighters when aroused.

Being the major hippo fan that I am, I would root for the hippopotamus. And before you shout "No way, Jose!" I would ask you to consider this excerpt from Bernhard Grzimek's essay "The African Black Rhinoceros," which appeared in Grzimek's Animal Life Encyclopedia, 1972, XIII, 57-58:

Guggisberg once watched a rhinoceros about to drink from a clear spring-fed pond in the Tsavo National Park. There a hippopotamus surfaced, grabbed the rhino's right front leg, pulled him down, and tore him to pieces with his huge tusks.
I'm not suggesting that this one anecdote settles the question once and for all. After all, the rhino in question was a Black rhino, which is considerably smaller than the White rhino. However, it does provide some food for thought, doesn't it?


Top of Page Return to How This Page Is Organized

Part 4: The Great Debate

 

Wherein I trade thoughts with a devoted rhino fan on various hippo/rhino issues

I knew that this page would eventually catch the attention of a rhino lover who would take issue with my conclusions. In November 1998 I began corresponding with rhinophile Matthew J. Patten. At first I manually added our e-mail messages to this page as I sent and received them. This quickly became cumbersome, so I decided to create a "guest book" where visitors could read our comments -- and add their own!

Hippo and Rhino reading
Read the debate thus far
   
Hippo and Rhino writing
Add your comments


Top of Page Return to How This Page Is Organized

Back Return to Wild Hippos

Back Return to Hippo World - Table of Contents

Revised 12 January 1999
URL: http://members.aol.com/HippoPage/hrquest.htm