![]() |
Shenango U. P.
Church Cemetery
|
The Shenango U. P. Church Cemetery is located in Neshannock Township on the corner of Wilmington Rd. (Rt. 18) and Shenango Rd.
Any comments within brackets [ ] are my own and not actually engraved on the tombstones. Names which are grouped together without a completely blank line separating them indicates that they are engraved on the same stone.
The Lawrence County Courthouse has death records Dec. 1893-Dec. 1905 from which I transcribed all the information I could find concerning those buried at the Shenango U. P. Church Cemetery. If someone died between those dates and is buried at the cemetery but I have no record listed for that person, it means that there IS no record for that person. For more information about Lawrence County death records, see my links page.
To obtain obituaries for any of these people, contact the New Castle Public Library. They have a Lawrence County obituary index file beginning in 1849 and divided into decades. In three cases, I stumbled upon marriage announcements in Lawrence County newspapers, transcriptions of which are provided on the obituary page. An incomplete index of such announcements is also at the library. For more information, see my links page.
I have provided a summarized history of the church and a number of biographical sketches concerning families with members buried in the cemetery as they appear in the 1877 History of Lawrence County, PA, and the 20th Century History of New Castle and Lawrence County, PA.
I also compiled some information from varying sources (which are fully listed at the bottom of the Military Records page) about the military service of those buried at the cemetery.
Other sources on this site include a 1898 article about the cemetery which appeared in the New Castle News. It has several transcriptions of epitaphs which can no longer be read on the stones. And because there are so many Thompsons buried in the cemetery, I provided a transcription of two Thompson family Bibles as well as a few tidbits of oral history (the latter of which is in the biography section).
Row 1
| COULTER, Jane death record obituary | d. Jan. 15, 1898 aged 72 yrs. |
| COULTER, Allen War of 1812 medallion death record obituary | d. Oct. 31, 1893 aged 72 yrs. |
| WILLIAMS, Mary Ann wife of Charles V. Williams | d. June 10, 1863 in her 39th year |
| M. A. W. G.A.R. medallion [NOTE: I could find no record of Charles V. Williams' military service.] |
Row 2
| KALNER, Albert M. son of J. F. & M. E. Kalner G.A.R. medallion [NOTE: I could find no record of J. F. Kalner's military service.] | d. Dec. 31, 1889 aged 21 ms. |
| KAUFMAN, Mary obituary | Oct. 10, 1820-Jan. 4, 1892 |
Row 3
| TANNER, George D. obituary TANNER, Eliza death record obituary TANNER, Eliza A. death record obituary And Children | 1858-1923 1865-1901 [death should be 1902] 1890-1904 |
| TANNER, infant male son of George & Eliza Tanner [NOTE: unmarked] death record | d. Dec. 16, 1898 aged 5
ds. |
| TANNER, infant male son George & Eliza Tanner [NOTE: unmarked] death record | d. May 11, 1902 aged 2
ds. |
| TANNER, Myrtle daughter of George & Eliza Tanner [NOTE: unmarked] death record obituary TANNER, William | d. Aug. 21, 1894 aged 6 wks. d. Mar. 27, 1885 aged 73 yrs. |
Row 4
| McKEE, Alexander obituary see biography of Robert H. Nesbitt | Feb. 23, 1864-Aug. 6, 1887 |
| HILL, Benjamin H. obituary EVANS, Harriet marriage announcement HILL, William Father obituary HILL, Samuel R. obituary | d. Oct. 5, 1889 aged 25 yrs., 3 ms. & 24 ds. Feb. 16, 1860-Jan. 10, 1896 1823-1911 d. July 30, 1894 aged 28 yrs., 5 ms. & 7 ds. |
| HOUSTON, William H. Pvt. Co. I 191 Reg. PA Vol. Inf. 1862-1865 - Civil War | |
| HOUSTON, William [H.] Father Co. G 10 P.V.R - Civil War military record obituary HOUSTON, Belinda Mother obituary | Jan. 8, 1836-Apr. 8, 1895 May 15, 1844-May 17, 1916 |
| McCONAHY, Rosie May daughter of Z. W. & M. E. McConahy [NOTE: Zenas W. & Mary E. McConahy are buried at King's Chapel M. E. Church Cemetery.] | d. Aug. 12, 1881 aged 1 yr., 8 ms. & 27
ds. |
| McCONAHY, Martha C. [grandmother of Rosie May] obituary | d. July 27, 1903 aged 78 yrs. |
| McCONAHY, Martha C. LEWIS, Clara M. nee McConahy McCONAHY, Smith C. son of Rev. J. & M. McConahy [John & Martha McConahy] McCONAHY, Rev. John biography of son Zenas W. | d. July 27, 1903 aged 78 yrs. d. May 2, 1887 aged 28 yrs. d. July 14, 1850 aged 1 yr. & 15 ds. d. Oct. 8, 1869 aged 46 yrs. |
| LEWIS, Clara M. nee McConahy LEWIS, baby Lillian | d. May 2, 1887 aged 28 yrs. 1887 |
| LOVE, William B. [NOTE: William B.'s wife was Sarah, but I could find no obituary for her to establish date of death or place of interment.] | d. Aug. 28, 1878 in his 60th year |
Row 5
| FOBES - Father & Mother [FOBES, Morgan obituary [FOBES, Margaret obituary | d. Oct. 30, 1890 aged 60 yrs.] Apr. 25, 1832-Dec. 28, 1928] |
| FOBES, Archie [grandchild of Morgan & Margaret Fobes] death record obituary | 1885-1890 aged 5 yrs. & 8 ms. |
| MILLER, Josephine nee Grannis obituary | d. Aug. 4, 1894 aged 37 yrs., 10 ms. & 3 ds. |
| MILLER, Margaret wife of John Miller obituary | d. Feb. 6, 1894 in her 79th year |
| MILLER, J. [John] obituary | d. Mar. 27, 1885 |
| FOBES, Bertha daughter of N. & M. J. Fobes obituary | d. Nov. 30, 1889 aged 1 yr., 1 m. & 10 ds. |
| J. R. | 1848-1898 |
| SANKEY, Mary A. wife of W. W. Sankey | d. Feb. 18, 1880 in her 24th year |
| FENNICK, Joseph W. Father | d. Oct. 11, 1901 aged 24 yrs. |
| BLEWS, Nettie daughter of A. & A. Blews [Aaron & Ann Blews] obituary BLEWS, Ann wife of Aaron Blews | d. Mar. 28, 1882 aged 14 yrs. & 5 ms. d. Dec. 2(8?), 1881 aged 56 yrs. |
| IRVIN, Thomas D. obituary military record IRVIN, William B. [Baxter] military record IRVIN, John B. death record obituary IRVIN, Amanda death record IRVIN, William IRVIN, Jane B. | Sept. 20, 1846-Feb. 2, 1874 d. Mar. 19, 1865 aged 22 yrs. June 21, 1818-June 24, 1899 Nov. 3, 1816-Jan. 9, 1900 June 23, 1773-June 22, 1851 June 7, 1777-Apr. 7, 1871 |
| IRVIN, Thomas Corp. Co. F 16 Cav. 1861-1865 - Civil War | |
| IRVIN, William B. Pvt. Co. F 100 Inf. 1861-1865 - Civil War |
Row 6
| SMITH, Robert A. son of Henry & Harriet Smith | d. May 2, 1858 aged 2 yrs. & 10 ms. & 19
ds. |
| PYLE, Joseph J. son of I. S. & Jennie Pyle [NOTE: Infant son of Isaac S. Pyle who was a captain in Co. H 100th Regiment PA Volunteer Infantry. In the 1870 census, he and wife Jennie lived in Neshannock Township and had a 1-year-old son Alexander. They do not appear in the 1880 Lawrence County census and eventually settled in Russell, IA.] father's military record | d. Sept. 21, 1876 aged 6 ms. & 17
ds. |
| SWEESY, Frank [probably a child of Alvah & Mandana] SWEESY, Charles [probably a child of Alvah & Mandana] SWEESY, Dana obituary SWEESY, mother [Mandana death record obituary SWEESY, John [probably a child of Alvah & Mandana] SWEESY, father [Alvah L. obituary military record | [d. Aug. 25, 1889 aged 1 yr. & 4 ms.] d. Jan. 6, 1897 aged 48 yrs.] d. Feb. 1, 1916 aged 68 yrs.] |
| SWEESY, Alvah Pvt. Co. I 6 Reg. H. Art. PA Vol. 1864-1865 - Civil War G.A.R. medallion |
Row 7
| THOMPSON, Mary I. [Isabel/la] daughter of James G. & Polly Thompson obituary | d. Apr. 22, 1857 aged 8 yrs., 3? ms. & 6 ds. |
| THOMPSON, Jane A. daughter of James G. & Polly Thompson obituary | d. June 4, 1857 aged 11 yrs. & 7 ds. |
| THOMPSON, Polly wife of J. G. Thompson [James Galloway Thompson] Revolutionary War medallion obituary | d. Sept. 10, 1858 aged 46 yrs., 5 ms. & 24 ds. |
| LINSLEY?, William son of D. & D.? Linsley? | d. Oct. 12, 1869 aged 2 yrs. & 1 m. |
| PYLE, Sarah Ann daughter of R. G. & M. Pyle [Richard Gardner & Mary Pyle] obituary | d. Feb. 28, 1873 aged 19 yrs., 6 ms. & 2 ds. |
| COX, Keziah Our Mother G.A.R. medallion [NOTE: Keziah was the wife of William Cox who died 1860-1870 censuses, but I could find no obituary for him. And I could find no record indicating who the G.A.R. medallion is for.] | d. Aug. 6, 1879 in her 74th year |
| KELSO, Christen J. son of H. & J. Kelso | d. Mar. 15, 1850 aged 8 ms. & 21 ds. |
| McGARY, Margaret wife of John McGary obituary McGARY, John biography of son George Wallace McGary | d. Aug. 22, 1894 in her 89th year d. Oct. 6, 1875 in his 73rd year |
| McGARY, Margaret J. daughter of J. & M. McGary | d. Sept. 17, 1850 aged 1 yr., 5 ms., & 11
ds. |
| W. R. |
Row 8
| LINDSY, George | May 26, 1808-Apr. 7, 1872 |
| LINDSY, Elisabeth H. daughter of G. & M. Lindsy | d. Apr. 21, 1860 aged 12 yrs. & 8 ms. |
| LINDSY, Sarah J. daughter of G. & M. Lindsy | d. Apr. 18, 1860 aged 16 yrs. & 2 ms. |
| LINDSEY, Thomas Dear Father [husband of Sarah Bay Lindsey in Row 9] obituary | 1806-1866 |
| McCREARY, Jane wife of Thomas McCreary | d. June 21, 1891 aged 80 yrs., 4 ms., & 28
ds. |
| McCREARY, Jane obituary McCREARY, Thomas death record obituary biography of father Samuel & of son Samuel Clark | 1811-1891 d. Jan. 18, 1899 aged 90 yrs., 2 ms. & 11 ds. |
| McCREARY, Thomas G.A.R. medallion [NOTE: I could find no record indicating who the G.A.R. medallion is for.] | 1808-1899 |
| McGARY, Aaron L. O. son of S. W. & M. McGary [NOTE: I believe he was a son of Samuel Wallace McGary and Mary Dicks, listed in the 1860 census as Amos aged 1 year.] | d. Jan. 21, 186(3?) aged 3? yrs., 11 ms. & 19
ds. |
Row 9
| BROWN, Mary D. [wife of William Brown] death record obituary | 1842-1895 |
| GRAHAM, Hannah wife of John Graham obituary | d. Dec. 16, 1872 aged 64 yrs. |
| GRAHAM, John obituary | d. Nov. 3, 1873 aged 67 yrs. |
| ROBINSON, Newel R. son of J. H.? & S. J. Robinson | d. Mar. 19, 1854 aged 5? yrs., 1 m. & 19
ds. |
| ROBINSON, Sarah Jane wife of James H.? Robinson [NOTE: Sarah Jane, 16 years old and unmarried, is listed with her parents John & Hannah Graham in the 1850 census, which makes Newel's possible age at death quite unlikely. I could find no obituary for him to clarify his age.] obituary | d. Mar. 25, 1854 aged 19 yrs., 11 ms. & 6
ds. |
| McCREARY, Florinda wife of F. C. McCreary [daughter of Thomas & Sarah Bay Lindsey] G.A.R. medallion [NOTE: I could find no military record for F. C. McCreary.] | d. Mar. 1, 1876 aged 24 yrs., 7 ms. & 21
ds. |
| GIBSON, infant son son of F. & S. E. Gibson | d. Feb. 25, 1883 |
| LINDSEY, Sarah nee Bay Dear Mother [wife of Thomas Lindsey in Row 8] death record obituary | 1811-1901 |
Row 10
| [unreadable] Revolutionary War medallion | |
| CLARK, Minnie E. CLARK, Harvey (F.?) CLARK, Harry F. children of S. D. & E. Clark [probably Samuel & Emma Clark] | d. Oct. 5, 1877 aged 10? yrs. & 9 ms. d. Oct. 15, 1877 aged 2 yrs. & 3 ms. d. Dec. 8, 1877 aged 2 yrs., 4 ms. & 23 ds. |
| SMITH, Lewis W. son of H. C. & L. Smith [Henry C. & Lovina Smith] | d. Jan. 24, 1872 aged 3 yrs., 6 ms., & 1 d. |
| SMITH, Lovina wife of H. C. Smith [Henry C. Smith] G.A.R. medallion [NOTE: Henry C. Smith is buried at Graceland Cemetery.] obituary husband's military record | d. Mar. 8, 1880 in her 40th year |
| BAY, Thomas F. obituary BAY, Nancy obituary | Aug. 31, 1806-Mar. 1, 1888 Aug. 3, 1814-Mar. 17, 1890 |
| FISHER, James | d. June 6, 1836 in his 27th year |
| HUNTER, Elizabeth wife of John Hunter last will & testament of John Hunter | d. May. 21, 1838 aged 54 yrs. |
Row 11
| DICKS, Mary wife of Aaron L. | d. Sept. 2, 1847 aged 49 yrs., 8 ms. & 3 ds. |
| DICKS, Aaron L. | d. Feb. 21, 1865 aged 69 yrs., 9 ms. & 11 ds. |
| THOMPSON, William S. | d. Apr. 6, 1851 aged 58 yrs. |
Row 12
| THOMPSON, Elizabeth M. | d. Apr. 7, 1851 aged 17 yrs. |
Row 13
| GOTT, Hanna GOTT, Thomas GOTT, Ralph obituary children of R. & M. Gott [Ralph and Margaret] | July 6, 1866-Sept. 2, 1867 Oct. 28, 1872-June 24, 1874 Mar. 23, 1869-July 31, 1891 |
| SAVAGE, Henry obituary | d. Mar. 30, 1864 aged 2(5?) yrs. |
| MAITLAND, Charlotte C. | Dec. 2?, 18(10?)-Aug. 12, 187(2?)/2- |
| MAITLAND, John obituary biography | d. May 29, 1861 aged 84 yrs., 3 ms. & 11
ds. born in Bucks Co., Pa. Feb. 18, 1777 |
| BAY, Nancy wife of William Bay | d. Aug. 19, 1861 in her 31st year |
| BAY, William death record military record obituary | 1826-1898 |
| THOMPSON, Eleanor daughter of W. S. & M. A. Thompson G.A.R. medallion [NOTE: I could find no record indicating who the G.A.R. medallion is for.] | d. Apr. 21/4, 184- aged 24/1 yrs. |
| THOMPSON, George M. obituary THOMPSON, Lydia [G.] wife of George M. obituary | d. Nov. 8, 1884 aged 61 yrs. d. Sept. 23, 1863 aged 29 yrs. |
| THOMPSON, Archibald son of W. S. & M. A. Thompson THOMPSON, Mary A. daughter of W. S. & M. A. Thompson | d. Apr. 26, 1831/4 aged 6 yrs. d. Apr. 27, 1831/4 aged 3 yrs. |
| THOMPSON, infant son son of G. M. & L. Thompson | d. Jan. 1851 |
| THOMPSON, Patterson W. son of W. S. & M. A. Thompson | d. Apr. 21, 1831 aged 4 yrs. |
| JELLISON, Rebecca (J.?) wife of William Jellison marriage announcement obituary | d. July 30, 1854 aged 21/4 yrs. |
| PENBERTHA, Richard Co. D 134 Pa. Vol. Inf. - Civil War G.A.R. medallion [NOTE: His death date is obviously incorrect because his obituary appeared in the paper on May 29, 1903. Also, his wife Rachel died in 1875, letters of administration being applied for Sept. 27, 1875, but no obituary could be found.] military record marriage announcement obituary | d. May 30, 1903 |
| IRWIN, Mattie (O.?) daughter of W. B. & R. E. Irwin [Warren B. & Rachel E. Irwin] | Oct. 4, 1870-Oct. 19, 1871 |
Row 14
| HILL, Dorothy Mae obituary | 1908-1924 |
| SMITH, George Corp. Co. H 100th Pa. Vol. - Civil War G.A.R. medallion obituary military record | 1842-1918 |
| SMITH, Harriet wife of George Smith [NOTE: unmarked] obituary | d. Nov. 1886 |
| CRAIG, Rachel T. nee Dicks obituary THOMPSON, Ezekiel S. obituary THOMPSON, Lydia obituary THOMPSON, Henry | Nov. 27, 1831-Feb. 25, 1902 d. Feb. 23, 1879 in his 72nd year d. Apr. 19, 1883 aged 78 yrs. [NOTE: Her year of death should be 1884.] d. June 23, 1879 in his 70th year |
| THOMPSON, Mary Anne wife of W. S. Thompson | d. Jan. 21, 1847 aged 53 yrs. |
| THOMPSON, Mary Anne daughter of R. & J. Thompson [Robert & Jennet Thompson] | d. Mar. 22, 1849 aged 45 yrs., 3 ms. & 23
ds. |
| THOMPSON, Jennet | d. Mar. 15, 1832 in her 62nd year |
| THOMPSON, Robert biography family Bible last will & testament | d. June 8, 1834 aged 73 yrs., 1 m. & 17
ds. |
Row 15
| WALTERS, Thomas Co. I 104 NY - Civil War G.A.R. medallion obituary military record | d. Feb. 27, 1895 aged 51 yrs. |
| BENNETT, Jane daughter of J. & J. Bennett [John & Jennett Bennett] | d. Apr. 22, 1875 aged 18 yrs., 2 ms. & 25
ds. |
| WATSON, William War of 1812 medallion military record | d. Dec. --, 18-- aged 62 yrs. |
| WATSON, William biography last will & testament | d. Oct. 2, 1841 in his 63rd year |
| WATSON, Sarah wife of William Watson | d. Apr. 6, 1831 in her 45th year |
| WATSON, Catherin | d. July 20, 1815 aged 4 yrs. & 3 ms. |
| WATSON, Jackson F. | d. July 13, 1816 aged 1 yr. & 7 ms. |
| THORNTON, Esther daughter of Joseph & Mary Thornton last will & testament | d. Oct. 25, 1812 aged 54 yrs. |
| BOYD, Martha consort of Robert Boyd daughter of Joseph & Mary Thornton | d. Feb. 20, 1813 aged 59 yrs. |
| THORNTON, Joseph [NOTE: The only evidence of his burial is in the 1898 New Castle News article about the cemetery.] biography last will & testament | d. Apr. 13, 1833 aged 94 yrs. |
| McGARY, Robert biography & biography of grandson George Wallace McGary | d. Aug. 19, 1838 aged 89? yrs. |
| SANKEY, Jane wife of Ezekiel Sankey obituary | d. Mar. 30, 1860 in her 93rd year |
| SANKEY, Ezekiel War of 1812 medallion military record biography last will & testament | d. July 9, 1813 in his 41st year |
Row 16
| McKEE, Emma four infants of D. & S. E. McKee [David & Sarah E. McKee] McKEE, Laura M. McKEE, John | June 22, 1862-June 27, 1862 Jan. 10, 1857-Jan. 27, 1860 d. May 12, 18(48?) in his 6(8?)th year |
Row 17
| BENNETT, Jennett wife of John Bennett | d. Jan. 21, 1871 aged 36 yrs. & 8 ms. |
| HUGHES, Rebecca Mother STEWART, Margaret | 1854-1888 d. Jan. 11, 186(5?) in her 92nd year |
| STEWART, David | d. June 12, 1855 in his 80th year |
| STEWART, Sarah wife of James Stewart G.A.R. medallion [NOTE: I could find no record of James Stewart's military service.] | d. Jan. 25, 1864 |
| [unreadable] |
Row 18
| PEARSON, Samuel | d. Jan.? 11, 1865 aged 93/5 yrs. |
| PEARSON, Sarah A. | d. Aug. 30, 1855 aged 72 yrs. |
| PEARSON, ---- wife of Samuel Pearson | d. --- 2(0?), 1839 in her 59th year |
| PEARSON, George son of S. & S. Pearson War of 1812 medallion [NOTE: Something has to be wrong here, because this would make him a soldier at age 6!! I strongly suspect that this George Pearson was mistaken for John Pearson's son George, this George's uncle, who WAS in the War of 1812 but is buried at Greenwood Cemetery, New Castle, PA.] | d. Jan./July 11, 1829 in his 23rd year |
| PEARSON, Margaret [NOTE: She may be the wife of John Pearson.] | |
| PEARSON, John Revolutionary War plaque military record biography last will & testament | Oct. 22, 1740-Jan. 22, 1829 born at Darby, Penn. |
| REYNOLDS, James biography Estate | 1760-1829 |
| by itself in NW corner of cemetery by the fence NESBITT, Ella May death record obituary NESBITT, Nellie P. [Pearl] 1876-1904 nee Smith death record biography of husband Robert H. obituary | 1904-1904 |
| ANDERSON, Edward L. death record obituary | d. Jan. 2, 1894 aged 16 yrs. |
| ANDERSON, Harry G. death record obituary | d. Oct. 25, 1895 aged 18 yrs. |
| AULTMAN/ALTMAN, Bertha daughter of S. D. & Netta Aultman death record obituary | d. Feb. 1902 aged 5 ds. |
| BADGER, Fannie daughter of David S. & Laura Badger death record obituary | d. Aug. 28, 1895 aged 5 ms. |
| BARNES, Cochran son of William A. & Anna Barnes death record obituary | d. July 11, 1904 aged 15 ds. |
| BAY, Dorcas nee Johnson wife of William V. Bay obituary | d. July 28, 1858 aged nearly 85 yrs. |
| BAY, William V. [NOTE: I assume he's buried here because his wife is.] obituary biography military record | d. Mar. 20, 1855 in his 85th year |
| BLEWS, Aaron [NOTE: I assume he's buried here because his wife is.] obituary | d. May 22, 1891 aged 66 yrs. |
| BUXTON, Sarah A. wife of Arcus Buxton & daughter of John J. & Nancy Bay Thompson obituary | d. Dec. 4, 1908 aged 65 yrs. |
| DAVIS, M. Elizabeth death record obituary | d. Feb. 9, 1902 aged 84 yrs. |
| DOUTHITT, John E. son of John W. & Ada L. Douthitt death record obituary | d. Sept. 23, 1894 aged 1 yr. |
| DOUTHITT, John W. death record obituary | d. Oct. 2, 1894 aged 32 yrs. |
| GOTT, Matilda death record obituary | d. Apr. 21, 1903 aged 75 yrs. |
| GRAHAM, Bessie J. daughter of Horace & Margaret Graham death record obituary | d. Jan. 1, 1901 aged 14 yrs. |
| HOGG, Lewis Edward son of Andy & Nancy Ann Hogg death record | d. Sept. 22, 1896 aged 6 1/2 yrs. |
| HOUSTON, Elmer son of George & Emma Houston death record | d. Sept. 13, 1902 aged 7 wks. |
| HOUSTON, Georgia daughter of George & Emma Houston death record obituary | d. Feb. 18, 1900 aged 9 ds. |
| HOUSTON, Jennie May daughter of Clarrit & Effa May Houston death record | d. Sept. 8, 1896 aged 5 yrs. |
| JAMES, Emily daughter of Robert & Prudence Ann James death record obituary | d. Nov. 1, 1895 aged 16 yrs. |
| KAHRER, Charles obituary | d. June 20, 1891 aged about 23 yrs. |
| KAUFMAN, George death record obituary | d. June 11, 1900 aged 47 yrs. |
| MAY, Mary Etta death record obituary | d. Nov. 8, 1895 aged 30 yrs. |
| MAYBERRY, Ezekiel son of Robert Mayberry death record obituary | d. Oct. 14, 1894 aged 31 yrs. |
| MAYBERRY, Robert death record obituary | d. Oct. 17, 1894 aged 73 yrs. |
| MEHARD, Rev. Thomas biography Estate | d. July 16, 1845 aged 29 yrs. |
| MITCHELL, James Mitchell family biography last will & testament | d. shortly after settling in area in 1806 |
| MITCHELL, Peter [NOTE: In same corner as Ezekiel & Jane Sankey, according to the 1898 New Castle News article about the cemetery.] Mitchell family biography last will & testament | b. 1774 d. June 28, 1843 |
| MITCHELL, William son of James Mitchell Mitchell family biography Estate | d. shortly after settling in area in 1806 |
| MORRIS, Richard son of William & Lizzie Morris death record obituary | d. Feb. 11, 1900 aged 15 yrs. |
| MORRIS, Samuel Wallace death record | d. Sept. 1, 1898 aged 25 yrs. |
| PATTON, Arthur son of James & Lizzie Patton death record | d. Oct. 28, 1897 aged 6 ds. |
| RAWSON, Ann death record | d. Apr. 14, 1895 aged 78 yrs. |
| REYNOLDS, Elijah death record obituary | d. Nov. 18, 1898 aged 76 yrs. |
| SIMONS, Floyd son of Samuel C. & Nina Simons death record obituary | d. Nov. 11, 1896 aged 7 wks. |
| SIMONS, Luella daughter of William & Mary Simons [probably a twin of Zella Simons] death record | d. Apr. 16, 1897 aged 4 ms. & 16 ds. |
| SIMONS, William son of Samuel & Nina Simons death record obituary | d. Dec. 12, 1897 aged 9 yrs. |
| SIMONS, Zella daughter of William & Mary Jane Simons [probably a twin of Luella Simons] death record | d. Oct. 12, 1897 aged 11 ms. |
| SMITH, Tabitha wife of James Smith [NOTE: I couldn't find out what happened to James, who died after the 1880 census and before his wife died.] death record obituary | d. Sept. 12, 1898 aged 68 yrs. |
| SPEER, David death record obituary | d. Apr. 29, 1898 aged 75 yrs. & 10 ms. |
| TANNER, Bell death record obituary | d. Feb. 6, 1899 aged 32 yrs. |
| TEECE, Bryan/Byron death record obituary | d. Feb. 5, 1900 aged 74 yrs. |
| TEECE, James B. death record obituary | d. Mar. 3, 1900 aged 39 yrs. |
| TEECE, Laura Myrtle daughter of James B. & Mary Ann Teece death record obituary | d. Oct. 13, 1893 aged 7 yrs. |
| TEECE, Maggie daughter of James B. & Mary Ann Teece death record obituary | d. Feb. 9, 1900 aged 14 yrs. |
| TEECE, Mary Ann wife of James B. Teece death record obituary | d. Jan. 27, 1900 aged 35 yrs. |
| TEECE, Orben son of James B. & Mary Ann Teece death record obituary | d. Sept. 8, 1894 aged 11 ds. |
| THOMPSON, Aaron D. son of Thomas & Sarah Hunter Thompson military record | d. Dec. 12, 1868 aged about 28 yrs. |
| THOMPSON, George M. son of William S. & Ella Thompson death record obituary | d. Sept. 26, 1898 aged 5 yrs. |
| THOMPSON, Henry death record | d. May 14, 1898 aged 38 yrs. |
| THOMPSON, Jennie daughter of John J. & Nancy Bay Thompson obituary | d. Nov. 20, 1888 aged 45 yrs. |
| THOMPSON, John J. husband of Nancy Bay Thompson obituary family Bible | d. Oct. 20, 1883 aged 72 yrs. |
| THOMPSON, Loy Oliver son of Oliver & Kate T. Thompson death record obituary | d. Dec. 1, 1894 aged 1 yr. |
| THOMPSON, Lydia Jane daughter of George M. & Lydia G. Thompson [NOTE: I assume she's buried here because her parents and siblings are.] obituary | d. Aug. 16, 1863 aged about 5 ms. |
| THOMPSON, Nancy nee Bay wife of John J. Thompson obituary | d. Mar. 29, 1891 aged 77 yrs. |
| WALLACE, Jane death record obituary | d. Dec. 19, 1898 aged 23 yrs. |