The Robert E. Lee Boyhood Home Virtual Museum

Correspondence of Samuel Appleton Storrow
(regarding "Light Horse Harry" Lee)


[This letter has been graciously provided by Mr. Eugene H. Leache, the g-g-g-grandson of the letter's author, Samuel Appleton Storrow[1], and Elizabeth Hill Farley Carter. It was first published in The Lees of Virginia by Burton J. Hendrick, pages 380–382. The footnotes shown reflect Mr. Leache's research and are drawn from both published sources and unpublished family records. Editorial comments displayed in braces (e.g., "{}") are also his.]

Edition 1, September 16, 2003

Copyright © 2003 by Eugene H. Leache; Maynard, Massachusetts All rights reserved


Farley[2] 6th Sept, 1821

My Dear Sister:[3]

I have delayed writing to you for some days, & a visit from Mrs. Lee has been the cause. She is our relation & our Mother's[4] earliest friend. It is fitting that I should explain the reason why I do now what I ought to have done a week since, & as the cause is Mrs. Lee.[5] I cannot do better than explain Mrs. Lee. In fact I am glad of this chance — I have an overflowing of the heart whenever I think of her & an outpouring of the spirit is the only relief.

Very fine women (you may doubt me) are rather rare here. Female talent has generally received a wrong direction. I have seen many a worn out coquette, many a heartless Belle that wonted but the first impulse to have been made useful & happy. I have heard of many instances of rare capacities, but waist {sic} followed possession as tho' it were irresistible. In fact it may have been so — society (that of Va. I mean) was full of splendid meteors: if a woman had been inclined to pursue a right path there was no steady light whereby she could discern it. But Mrs. Lee need not have been in Va. to have been pronounced excellent — there is no circle — none on earth — of which she would not be an ornament. She commenced life a spoilt child — a beauty & fortune — but Heaven has used her as it purest gold & all that died under the torture were her imperfections. My Mammy you know was a beauty & fortune too in her day — Nancy Lee & herself were pretty much brought up together — Mrs. Lee the eldest by a year.[6] Gen. Lee,[7] at that time the head of everything in Va., was in love (honestly they say) with Mrs. Carter. He was handsome, of splendid talents, & Governor of the State. Mrs. Carter, then Miss Farley, & Mrs. Lee, then Miss Carter, were living together during the Gen.'s suit to Miss Farley[8] as desperately as was Gen. Lee in love with Miss F—— was Miss Carter with Gen. Lee & at the same time compelled to witness his devotion to another object. His repeated visits to Miss F—— & utter neglect of her preyed upon her health — but drew nothing from her of unkindness to her fortunate cousin. & her only interference, & that against herself, was when General Lee had made his offer and Miss Farley avowed that she should reject it — she then said "O stop, stop Maria — you do not know what you are throwing away." Maria[9] however persisted in throwing it away. & then in the face of decency & delicacy he made an offer to her,[10] which she could not resist, & became his delighted wife, but to find in the short space of a fortnight that her affections were trampled on by a heartless & depraved profligate. I am right as to time. One fortnight was her dream of happiness from which she awoke to a life of misery. Her fortune was soon thrown away upon his debts contracted previous to marriage: She was despised & neglected. & he, who in his outset of life bid fairer for a glorious termination of it that perhaps any man in America died a vagrant & Beggar. Gen. Lee at the time of his marriage with her was a widdower {sic}. By his first marriage he had two children — one daughter married and proved to be everything that was abominable,[11] the other a son, was the kindest & to his new Mother & her children the most affectionate relation on earth. Mrs. L—— herself had five children.[12] Just as Carter Lee (whom you recollect in college)[13] had proved himself a fine fellow, her eldest daughter Ann[14] was attacked with a dreadful complaint in the hand, & after a year's residence in Philadelphia for the sake of medical assistance & after sufferings of a most horrible sort, was informed that her life was to be saved only by the amputation of her arm. The Mother had infused a portion of her own heroism into her daughter & about six months since — after eighteen months exercise of it the sweet little creature was pronounced convalescent.

One misery ceased but to prepare the way for a greater. Henry Lee — her husband's son — a gentleman of great fortune & talents — more distinguished perhaps than any young man in Virginia for excellence of various sorts. His genius, liberality, his devotion to his Mother's family & promise of eminence being the theme of everyone was convicted of crimes of the blackest dye. He married a Lady of fortune[15] & her sister lived with him. He was guardian. He seduced her under circumstances too — too horrible to mention & blackened with his disgrace everyone that bore his name.[16] This is {sic} the last fatal — fatal stroke seems to have left no phial unemptied. And yet when you see her you do not require the consideration of her suffering to give interest to her. Her simple dignity, her most admirable understanding & manners excite enough admiration without any appeal to sympathy.

This is the history of the Lady who has kept my letter back & it is a most edifying one. Misery & temptation have beset her from the outset & their only effects have been to raise her nearer to Heaven. Carter & her youngest daughter Mildred were with her.[17] They left us this morning. Sept. 10th. After writing the foregoing I stopt {sic} for breath, as well I might. You see that the parting continued for four days. Finding myself better in mind than I was, I go at it again.

{Remainder of correspondence missing}


NOTES

[1] Samuel Appleton Storrow [1787-1837] was a member of a Massachusetts clan that achieved prominence in the 19th and 20th centuries. He attended Harvard University (1803-1807) and served as a Judge Advocate of the U. S. Army on the staff of General Jacob Jennings Brown in Washington, D.C., from 1816-1820. In 1819 he married Elizabeth Hill Farley Carter [1794-1870], the daughter of William Champe Carter (of Blenheim) and Maria Byrd Farley (of Westover), and moved to "Farley", the Carter's plantation.
[2] Farley plantation, Brandy Station, Virginia
[3] Samuel Storrow characteristically wrote interchangeably to his two sisters, Louisa Appleton Storrow (the Mrs. Stephen Higginson) and Ann Gillam Storrow, who subsequently exchanged his correspondence with one another. The Storrow sisters lived in Massachusetts.
[4] Mother's - It is quite unlikely that this reference is to Samuel Appleton Storrow's mother, but rather to his mother-in-law, Maria Byrd Farley, the Mrs. William Champe Carter.
[5] Ann Hill Carter, who was married to Gen. Henry "Light Horse Harry" Lee on June 18, 1793. (Burton J. Hendrick, The Lees of Virginia, page 377). At the time this letter was written, she was a widow, Henry Lee having died March 25, 1818 (Ibid, page 397).
[6] Mammy – his mother-in-law, Maria Byrd (Farley) Carter [1774-1852]. Nancy – familiar for Ann Hill (Carter) Lee [1773-1829]. herself – again, Maria Byrd (Farley) Carter.
[7] Gen. Lee – General Henry "Light Horse Harry" Lee, who served illustriously in the Revolutionary War, was well known to George Washington, and later was governor of Virginia. He and Ann Hill Carter were to become the parents of Robert E. Lee.
[8] Perhaps Shirley or Westover.
[9] Generations of female descendents bearing this name pronounced it "Mariah", presumably she did as well.
[10] her - Ann Hill Carter
[11] Lucy Grymes Lee [1786-1860]
[12] Five children: apparently discounting Algernon Sidney Lee, who died as an infant.
[13] Charles Carter Lee was at Harvard in 1816. (Emory M. Thomas, Robert E. Lee: A Biography, page 45)
[14] Anne Kinlock Lee
[15] Anne Robinson McCarty [1797-1840]. (David J. Eicher, Robert E. Lee: A Life Portrait, page 201)
[16] Earning Henry Lee IV [1787-1837] the name "Blackhorse Harry". (Ibid, page 201)
[17] Carter: Charles Carter Lee. Mildred: Catherine Mildred Lee.


BIBLIOGRAPHY

The Lees of Virginia, Burton J. Hendrick, Little, Brown, and Company, Boston, 1935
The Lees of Virginia, Paul C. Nagle, Oxford University Press, New York, 1990
Robert E. Lee: A Biography, Emory M. Thomas, W. W. Norton & Company, New York, 1995 Robert E. Lee: A Life Portrait David J. Eicher, Taylor Publishing Company, Dallas, 1997
George Washington in the American Revolution (1775-1783), James Thomas Flexner, Little Brown and Company, Boston, 1967.